Friday, July 10, 2015

Round 4: Campus-Community Partnerships & To Hell with Good Intentions

Friday, July 10

Readings:
"Developing a Theory and Practice of Campus-Community Partnerships" by Sandra Enos and Keith Morton (see email for PDF)

"To Hell with Good Intentions" by Ivan Illich

--

In the first article ("Developing a Theory...") one of the goals the authors have in mind is to address how institutions of higher education promote justice in neighborhoods as opposed to charity. It's a somewhat subtle point, but I think it underlies much of what they're trying to do. What do you think the authors mean when they say, "The neighbors of colleges and universities, we believe, are asking for justice and receiving charity" (p. 23)?

In the comparison between transactional and transformative SL relationships, what characteristics resonated most with you? I found it challenging to think about abiding by this fully. Of course we can agree in principle that a transformative relationship is better, but my experience on both sides of the relationship (as a "provider" and a "receiver") has been that when the rubber meets the road it's most common to find a sweet spot where we both get the most of what we want out of a relationship. I don't mean to say that lightly, but I think the practical application of this component of SL is very, very challenging. What are your thoughts about how we take seriously a call to transformative relationships?

Enos & Morton also give a framework for development of partnerships and describe a number of types of service within that framework. In thinking about your role for the coming school year, where does your field (streetfest, spring break, transportation, etc.) fall within the typology they present? How might recurring "one-time events" potentially impact the weaknesses Enos and Morton identify with this type of service?

Lastly, for the article by Illich, "To Hell with Good Intentions," I want to acknowledge that this is not an easy piece to read. It may call into question some of the key motives for our desire to be involved in Service-Learning, but it's important to take the critiques seriously. The article was written in the late 60s, and we have to keep this in mind. In some ways Illich may have been dealing with a slightly different context in which "missions" were overwhelmingly driven by a sense of Western cultural superiority and patronizing motives. On the other hand, though, many of these same motives still grip those compelled to serve "the others" around the world. Keeping in mind Enos and Morton's chapter calling us to take seriously the transformative potential for SL relationships rather than finding a place of greatest mutual benefit, how might you respond to Illich's article? Have we made progress since the 60s in our ability to quiet our voices and listen to the other in order truly to work together to transform one another? Or, using Illich's example, are our languages simply too different to understand one another? Don't be afraid to wrestle with this. In light of Illich's critiques, how do we justify our goal to serve?

Best,


-tw

1 comment:

  1. I'd like to first respond to "Building Partnerships for Service-Learning", whereby I will then follow up with a response to "To Hell with Good Intentions"

    Our author for our text on building partnerships makes a very blunt point when asking whether or not our institutions, which are situating within cities, are acting as good neighbors to those around us. Are we proving meaningful friendships, partnerships, service, respect, and care to our city, one such as Grand Rapids, or is there another narrative we need to look at to get a clearer picture? Jacoby gives the examples of student renters driving up the prices of local housing, institutional expansion tearing down community centers and parks, and graduates applying for jobs without the necessary. All quite unique in their own respect these issues are, but I find that they all still fall under the umbrella of the life of the institution. All of these efforts, or lack-there-of, of ours fall under the umbrella of our institutional goals for all students, staff, and faculty to, "think deeply, act justly, and live wholeheartedly.."

    In what areas have we succeeded, and in what areas do we need serious conviction to alter our ways, and as Jeremiah puts it, "seek the welfare of the city?" What is it we can do as college educated students and faculty can do to seek the good for all people in our city? I would love to think that the answer lies simply within the realm of our ability to do more good things, but I do not find that to be the case. I hold to the idea that we only truly seek justice and human flourishing for people and institutions when we have bumped into these things head on and seen the pain and the unrest. My encourage therefore, if we are to be prepared for careers with the proper skills, fight to lower housing costs, and curb institutional expansion, we must first walk across the street and meet our neighbor. Our desire and zeal to do good things will result in nothing good at all without a dear friend from with whom we can fight. And even then, this may not be enough, as our goal ought never be to do good things, but to be faithful to our calling as people of the resurrection.

    Response to “To Hell With Good Intentions”
    A poem

    Forgive me, my Lord and my God.
    Forgive me each time I speak of other,
    With such disregard for circumstances,
    needs,
    and dignity.
    I repent, for I too often want to be you,
    Your whole physical body, rather than
    The single hand, or single feet to which I have been called.

    Your people mean well, of this I’m sure, but so blinded
    Are we, as if mud and muck sloshes in our eyes;
    Our hearts, chained and shackled by ignorance and comfort.
    Our mouths, twisted and contorted like a slithering snake spewing
    Sentences of superiority.

    Oh, forgive us. Our foolishness is too great, our wisdom is
    Too little and our reliance on you, faltering and failing.

    But we hope because we reign, because you reign, but
    Out of our mess and misconceptions you raise us up.
    A people of grace and redemption you called us to be.

    ReplyDelete