"Successful Service Learning: A Matter of Ideology" by Lisa Dicke, Sara Dowden, & Jodi Torres.
--
The authors in this week's article quote Barbara Jacoby in noting that
experiences themselves don’t necessarily cultivate formative education, but it
is reflection on those experiences that does so. They mention this in passing, but it is very important to notice. We can think of many tools used
for facilitating constructive reflection--from communal dialogue to personal
journaling. In thinking about cultivating growth with our fellow students this coming year, we should know how best to facilitate reflection. What reflective tools have been the most formational for your own
constructive processing of experiences?
The main part of the authors' article is identifying the various ideological perspectives service-learning
can emerge from, and they provide four: community service, moral development, political activism, and an instrumental perspective (i.e., strictly as an educational tool). The point they are arguing is that learning outcomes for service-learning depend on the ideology we are working from when we approach service-learning. In thinking about the four perspectives of service-learning, how do you see them playing into the various areas of S-L at
Calvin? As read in the article, different people may believe certain ideological perspectives are
more important than others. The authors argue that a hierarchy of importance is
not useful—what do you think?
In case study 1, the authors describe a “failed”
service-learning venture; it's attributed a failure not because of lack of student benefit,
but because the benefit students identified didn’t match those the instructors
had set out to achieve. Think about how this fits with your coming year of S-L leadership: how important is it that we establish specific outcome
goals in your projects for the year?
Case study 2 identifies the undeniable reality that even
with controlled measures, service-learning experiences remain open to
unexpected and unpleasant experiences. The experience in this case study was awful, but also
realistic. Having confronted it (or having been confronted by it…) opened
the reflection process up to deeper discussion than could have been built into the service-learning goals. How do we create
reasonable, realistic goals while also remaining open to unexpected opportunities?
The authors make the following statement as they begin to draw final conclusions: “Many community organizations are eager to put unpaid
service learning students to work, but it is up to faculty members to fully
scrutinize potential projects to ensure that they include dimensions that bring
about desired learning outcomes” (85). I invite you to put this quote
into conversation with the articles from our Round 4 readings (“Developing a
Theory and Practice of Campus-Community Partnerships” and “To Hell with Good
Intentions”). This quote is clearly written from a perspective of meeting the
institution’s “bottom line,” but we must remember the demand for reciprocity
and the goal of mutual transformation. How do we best discern the opportunities that best represent this high and difficult call?