Friday, July 24, 2015

Round Five: What We Don't Talk About When We Don't Talk About Service

Friday, July 24

Readings:
“What We Don’t Talk About When We Don’t Talk About Service” by Adam Davis.

--

The article this week is short, but it's power packed. Davis argues doing service purely for the sake of doing it is not inevitably a good thing. In response, we need to increase our talking about service so we don't miss critical points service-providers may overlook while basking in their (/our) good deeds.

Davis identifies five common motivations for our service, many of which have resonated with me at various times in my life (and still do sometimes). Which do you find yourself most confronted with? After reading the whole article, how would you respond to your own motivations now? Are these motivations totally misplaced? Are they completely valid? Or do they carry a more nuanced place in your heart/mind--maybe holding some merit amidst reluctance?

The heart of the article comes in the last two pages (153-154). Davis makes a suggestion that's a tough pill to swallow: "What's the dirty little secret? Maybe this: we cherish inequality" (153). He goes on to write that one only has to look around with open eyes to see clearly not all people are born equal--we are all born into particular contexts with varying levels of privilege and access to opportunities. In order to serve in a way that's truly good, we must take seriously the inequalities that give rise to our notions for the need of service. To do this, Davis' big take home is that we must grapple with the reality that "service is not simple."

In addition to the standard reflection questions (e.g., "what did this make you think/feel?"), the two questions in the last page of the PDF are valuable to think about:

What are the external and internal goods in the service that takes place with your partnership?

How will this article shape your service and your leadership in this coming year?

3 comments:

  1. As I reflect upon the article "What we don't talk about when we don't talk about service," I am drawn to think about the intersection of our prayer life and the service-learning that we do. I am thinking about this within the context of the work that I do with the Food Recovery Network here in Grand Rapids. Thinking about how we do the work that we do in partnering with different organizations in the area has me wondering about how we are bridging the inequality gaps, that we as an organization benefit from unfortunately, as without them, we would not exist. It's a tricky line that we must balance, and any service organization for that matter, because when I think about the character of God and the plans stored up for the renewal of all things, I suppose our goal is to be without our job in the service sector, for there would be no need. But until that day comes, we live faithfully and seek to bridge the gaps. I think of the poem, "A Step Along the Way." We plant the seeds that one day will grow, and though it may not be complete, it is something and an opportunity for the Lord's grace to enter in and do the rest. So we start here; service is not simple. It is tricky, messy, and can easily be manipulated. Five days from now, five weeks from now, five years from now, our interactions matter, no matter how big or small.

    I'd love to take time this summer and re-evaluate how we do work with FRN and whether or not we are actually bridging gaps, or whether we're simply, as our author puts it, trying to be good. My prayer moving forward for myself, for our office at the Service-Learning Center, and for the Food Recovery Network, is that our work would always be God's work; that our desire to bridge gaps of inequality would be birthed out of a deep, intimate understanding of the person of Jesus.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cam, thanks again for your honest appraisal of the article's impact on your current involvement at the Food Network. The organization side of the nonprofit world is very tricky--do we truly aim to work ourselves out of a job? What does that look like over time for funding and my role within the work that's being done? You're asking good questions.

      I'm intersted in your opening comparison between service-learning and prayer life. Can you hash that out more? Is prayer life important because it gives space for "talking" about service? Is there something else about the rhythm or practice that makes it valuable?

      Thanks for sharing your thoughts.

      Delete