Friday, July 24
Readings:
“What We Don’t Talk About When We Don’t Talk About
Service” by Adam Davis.
--
The article this week is short, but it's power packed. Davis argues doing service purely for the sake of doing it is not inevitably a good thing. In response, we need to increase our talking about service so we don't miss critical points service-providers may overlook while basking in their (/our) good deeds.
Davis identifies five common motivations for our service, many of which have resonated with me at various times in my life (and still do sometimes). Which do you find yourself most confronted with? After reading the whole article, how would you respond to your own motivations now? Are these motivations totally misplaced? Are they completely valid? Or do they carry a more nuanced place in your heart/mind--maybe holding some merit amidst reluctance?
The heart of the article comes in the last two pages (153-154). Davis makes a suggestion that's a tough pill to swallow: "What's the dirty little secret? Maybe this: we cherish inequality" (153). He goes on to write that one only has to look around with open eyes to see clearly not all people are born equal--we are all born into particular contexts with varying levels of privilege and access to opportunities. In order to serve in a way that's truly good, we must take seriously the inequalities that give rise to our notions for the need of service. To do this, Davis' big take home is that we must grapple with the reality that "service is not simple."
In addition to the standard reflection questions (e.g., "what did this make you think/feel?"), the two questions in the last page of the PDF are valuable to think about:
What are the external and internal goods in the service that takes place with your partnership?
How will this article shape your service and your leadership in this coming year?
Friday, July 24, 2015
Friday, July 10, 2015
Round 4: Campus-Community Partnerships & To Hell with Good Intentions
Friday, July 10
Readings:
"Developing a Theory and Practice of Campus-Community Partnerships" by Sandra Enos and Keith Morton (see email for PDF)
"To Hell with Good Intentions" by Ivan Illich
--
In the first article ("Developing a Theory...") one of the goals the authors have in mind is to address how institutions of higher education promote justice in neighborhoods as opposed to charity. It's a somewhat subtle point, but I think it underlies much of what they're trying to do. What do you think the authors mean when they say, "The neighbors of colleges and universities, we believe, are asking for justice and receiving charity" (p. 23)?
In the comparison between transactional and transformative SL relationships, what characteristics resonated most with you? I found it challenging to think about abiding by this fully. Of course we can agree in principle that a transformative relationship is better, but my experience on both sides of the relationship (as a "provider" and a "receiver") has been that when the rubber meets the road it's most common to find a sweet spot where we both get the most of what we want out of a relationship. I don't mean to say that lightly, but I think the practical application of this component of SL is very, very challenging. What are your thoughts about how we take seriously a call to transformative relationships?
Enos & Morton also give a framework for development of partnerships and describe a number of types of service within that framework. In thinking about your role for the coming school year, where does your field (streetfest, spring break, transportation, etc.) fall within the typology they present? How might recurring "one-time events" potentially impact the weaknesses Enos and Morton identify with this type of service?
Lastly, for the article by Illich, "To Hell with Good Intentions," I want to acknowledge that this is not an easy piece to read. It may call into question some of the key motives for our desire to be involved in Service-Learning, but it's important to take the critiques seriously. The article was written in the late 60s, and we have to keep this in mind. In some ways Illich may have been dealing with a slightly different context in which "missions" were overwhelmingly driven by a sense of Western cultural superiority and patronizing motives. On the other hand, though, many of these same motives still grip those compelled to serve "the others" around the world. Keeping in mind Enos and Morton's chapter calling us to take seriously the transformative potential for SL relationships rather than finding a place of greatest mutual benefit, how might you respond to Illich's article? Have we made progress since the 60s in our ability to quiet our voices and listen to the other in order truly to work together to transform one another? Or, using Illich's example, are our languages simply too different to understand one another? Don't be afraid to wrestle with this. In light of Illich's critiques, how do we justify our goal to serve?
Best,
-tw
Readings:
"Developing a Theory and Practice of Campus-Community Partnerships" by Sandra Enos and Keith Morton (see email for PDF)
"To Hell with Good Intentions" by Ivan Illich
--
In the first article ("Developing a Theory...") one of the goals the authors have in mind is to address how institutions of higher education promote justice in neighborhoods as opposed to charity. It's a somewhat subtle point, but I think it underlies much of what they're trying to do. What do you think the authors mean when they say, "The neighbors of colleges and universities, we believe, are asking for justice and receiving charity" (p. 23)?
In the comparison between transactional and transformative SL relationships, what characteristics resonated most with you? I found it challenging to think about abiding by this fully. Of course we can agree in principle that a transformative relationship is better, but my experience on both sides of the relationship (as a "provider" and a "receiver") has been that when the rubber meets the road it's most common to find a sweet spot where we both get the most of what we want out of a relationship. I don't mean to say that lightly, but I think the practical application of this component of SL is very, very challenging. What are your thoughts about how we take seriously a call to transformative relationships?
Enos & Morton also give a framework for development of partnerships and describe a number of types of service within that framework. In thinking about your role for the coming school year, where does your field (streetfest, spring break, transportation, etc.) fall within the typology they present? How might recurring "one-time events" potentially impact the weaknesses Enos and Morton identify with this type of service?
Lastly, for the article by Illich, "To Hell with Good Intentions," I want to acknowledge that this is not an easy piece to read. It may call into question some of the key motives for our desire to be involved in Service-Learning, but it's important to take the critiques seriously. The article was written in the late 60s, and we have to keep this in mind. In some ways Illich may have been dealing with a slightly different context in which "missions" were overwhelmingly driven by a sense of Western cultural superiority and patronizing motives. On the other hand, though, many of these same motives still grip those compelled to serve "the others" around the world. Keeping in mind Enos and Morton's chapter calling us to take seriously the transformative potential for SL relationships rather than finding a place of greatest mutual benefit, how might you respond to Illich's article? Have we made progress since the 60s in our ability to quiet our voices and listen to the other in order truly to work together to transform one another? Or, using Illich's example, are our languages simply too different to understand one another? Don't be afraid to wrestle with this. In light of Illich's critiques, how do we justify our goal to serve?
Best,
-tw
Wednesday, July 8, 2015
On Yuccies, Vocation, and Tithing
On
Yuccies, Vocation, and Tithing
This post recognizes Wolterstorff’s and Berg’s ability to
capture the dynamic nature of thoughts among people, which we may call “movements,”
or “culture,” or even, as Wolterstorff said, “stages.” Although quite
different, David Infante has recently tried to do the same.
Jeff, in his article, “Faithfully Present: Building the Universe,
Each in Our Own Inexplicable Ways,” briefly mentions the yuppie, “the
student that views college as a passport to privilege.”
New theory has come out on a current
young adult subculture, the yuccie: a new brand of millennial mixing the yuppie
and hipster.
The term seems to be created and
introduced by David Infante on a Mashable
post, a news outlet for the “digital
age.” He says that yuccies are “borne of suburban comfort, indoctrinated with the
transcendent power of education, and infected by the conviction that not only
do we deserve to pursue our dreams; we should profit from them.” If yuppies
were defined by ambition and money, with hipsters then rejecting the status-seeking
of the yuppies for a creative lifestyle, yuccies want both. In Infante’s words,
“Getting rich quick and preserving
creative autonomy? That’s the yuccie dream.”
Think microbreweries, personal photography businesses, and home-made
leather goods, stationary--anything the DYI mind can imagine.
Ultimately, what these labels
(yuccie, hipster, etc.) tell us is that we do have overlying principles that guide
our lives. And whether these principles are lived out in a Reformed way (we
think which shapes what we do), or in the Anabaptist style (we do which shapes
the way we think and be), the truth is that we can quantify trends in action
and behavior, distilling down the values of a culture--in this case, the yuccie
values of ambition + creativity.
The questions surrounding this are
enormous. What forms us as human beings? Is it thoughts, beliefs, or worldviews?
Is it our actions, practices, and liturgies? It is our questions? Or, as my
cousin, a Christian ethicist, once wondered with me, are we formed by what we
love? That ultimately, we were created to love and to be a Christian is less
about subscribing to certain beliefs but rather loving certain things over
others (Jesus, the poor) and putting certain loves to death (i.e. money)?
But questions about formation quickly
lead to questions of identity. Can a yuccie be a Christian? Would they be a
Christian yuccie? A yuccie Christian? What might that mean? The leading
formative virtues of the yuccie—ambition and creativity--aren’t necessarily in
combat with the Christian ethos. We strive to do our best (but not for
ourselves), and we are, after all, made in the image of the Creator.
At this kiss of thought and action,
belief and practice, the word vocation comes to mind. Vocation (as Jeff will be
quick to point out) is a word that has often been deflated in our community to
one of two extremes: snarky, cynicism-laced comments on the one side and clichéd
pleasantries on the other. In my understanding, the word is too big--to
spiritual-- for us humans to fully say what it is, but it might be too prideful
to simply try to point out what it's not.
I question if the yuccie’s (or our
culture’s) prescription of our vocation will ever be quite right. But I also wonder
if one age old practice of the church (and many other world religions for that
matter) can help us hold on to the thread of a vocational life wherever or
whatever we are "doing." That practice is tithing--a weekly, embodied
ritual of giving. Of saying that what we have (ambition, creativity) was not
ever ours in the first place, but a gift. And recognizing that furthermore, we
use the gifts that we were given not for ourselves, but for God by serving our
neighbor. It's to trust that amidst college loans and unpaid internships, God
is faithful, even to our fragile finances.
Before college began, I remember
sitting down with my dad and going over bank accounts, loans—money stuff. I
mentioned tithing, “Should I set up one of those fancy accounts that automatically
takes 10% from my income?” He eyed my bills, budgets, and spreadsheets. “I
don’t think that’s necessary. You are going to a Christian school. That is
enough.” I understand where my Dad was coming from, but I don’t agree with him.
Although my tuition is four times that of my brother’s secular school, I just
don’t see myself—even in the college years—to be outside of our Christian call
to tithe. This call to give for the sake of giving, to worship God with our
money, instead of worshipping money as our God. To proclaim, upon each
paycheck, Who owns this world.
This is not to say that I don’t
struggle with it. 10% didn’t seem like much to my naïve eyes, but when loans
start piling up and interest begins accruing, that toss into the offering plate
is more and more an act of trust.
Whether we are yuccies, yuppies,
hipsters, or none of the above, we are called to this liturgy of trust. In
fact, it’s a matter of God’s grace that he’s given us tools—e.i. the Ten
Commandments, church practices such as tithing and prayer—so that whatever
culture or subculture we are in, through the empowerment of the Holy Spirit, we
can offer our lives to God.
maaike.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)