Friday, May 29
Readings:
“The Mission of
the Christian College at the End of the 20th Century” by Nicholas
Wolterstorff
--
Alright folks, the piece by Nicholas Wolterstorff was short, but dense. He traced a bit of history for Christian higher education in North America: first, the crises Christian higher education faced when secular academia began questioning core tenets of traditional Christian faith and then the evolution of responses to this identity crisis. With the emergence of evolution and modern biblical criticism, Christian higher education’s first response was to “go underground.” It was sort of like intellectual fight or flight in response to the fear felt about being discredited by the larger world of higher education. The second stage was to integrate scholarship and faith. Wolterstorff says the rules of play in this second stage are to lean into the tensions and seek both to find and to appropriate truth where truth may be found. Christian colleges and universities in Stage II focused on training students to master the works of culture significant to their particular fields. Wolterstorff, writing this essay in 1983, placed Christian higher education at that time in the midst of a paradigm shift from Stage II into a new and still undefined third stage, which would embrace the fruit of the first two stages while also incorporating a focus on society. Christian education would aim to equip students to live distinctly as members of society, actively involved in renewal of the places they inhabit.
As I think back on my own experiences, Wolterstorff’s stages have taken place on a micro-level in my life. My experience at Calvin in particular was a convoluted mixture of all three stages, any one of them being more operative than another in various experiences. Jeff’s article provides a really helpful description of the SLC’s thoughtful involvement with Calvin students from the very beginning of their career here. I found the level of intentionality the SLC has taken in Streetfest, for example—using the Rapid for transportation, writing thank you letters to the t-shirt company for fair employee treatment, etc.—completely inspiring. If I’m honest, though, as a student the value of these experiences went totally over my head. What didn’t go over my head, though, was the work we did that day (passing out flyers!) and an initial experience that implicitly told me I was a part of Calvin College, which is a place that belongs to a larger place, which is surrounded by many other places, and that all of these places make up an even larger “place.” Perhaps even more important yet was that all of these “places” were made up of people—exactly what Wolterstorff insists we must remember.
At the time I didn’t have the language to think or to talk about my Streetfest experience in this way, but somewhere in my subconscious it planted a seed that would continue take root. As I later became involved in community development, led a Spring Break Trip, and eventually moved to Mississippi, the set of questions I began to bring into scholarship changed, and this is where we find the greatest value of service-learning. Service-learning does not always provide clear answers, but it equips us to ask better questions. When we ask better questions, we take into consideration the wholeness of what it means to be human. Each of us is a human being, but each is also human knowing and human doing. Each is also a human feeling and human loving. Humanity can’t be limited to one of these without considering the others, and service-learning attempts to integrate all of these components. Wolterstorff’s third stage is a call not to abandon classrooms, but to think of classrooms as rooms with glass walls. We learn while remaining mindful of our presence in the midst of particular space and time; what happens in the classroom takes place in the world and for the world. For those of us who are Christians, we live and learn as witnesses to God’s Reign within that world.
Questions to reflect on:
In thinking about Wolterstorf’s stages of Christian higher education, how have you seen these stages in your own development? What has formed you the most as a human being, human doing, human knowing, human feeling, and human loving?
In what ways might service-learning speak into and enhance the development of human being, human knowing, human doing, human feeling, and human loving?
-tw
The articles, and this reflection, reminded me of another reflection written by Joy Liu and published in the Undergraduate Journal of Service Learning and Community-Based Research. Here's the link: http://www.bk.psu.edu/Documents/Academics/Liu.pdf
ReplyDeleteIt's a bit long. The following sections are the ones that came to mind: the first paragraph on page 1 and the last full paragraph on page 4 to the end.
I like her reflection on "being with." Being with is being present.
Regarding the first reflection question: the phrasing of human being, human doing, human knowing reminds me of something I read from Emerson (I think it was him). Anyway, the author was explaining why he preferred the phrasing of " a person that teaches" vs. "a teacher." The reason is that the former has primary focus on the person and secondary focus on what the person does. In the latter, the noun-verb mesh together. The person's identity becomes tied to what he or she does.
The reason that that's important is because it is very easy to label ourselves as X thing. In doing so, we are limiting ourselves. That is the reason that Christian higher education went underground--the identity of Christian higher ed as it stood could not stay in tact in the face of evolution.
Now, to actually answer the question: just as Christian higher ed has moved/is moving to a more complex stage, so have I, I think. At the very least, I understand things in a less binary way, and I am over trying to make things fit into binary categories.
I think listening to stories has formed me the most. Stories in books, stories of people, life stories of friends, story line of movies, overheard stories, all stories.
Now, regarding the second question: Service-learning should have threads of "being with." In "being with," there are no labels, no boxes, and no personal agendas. I mean, yes, that's a lie, but those things don't guide the relationship, nor are they the foundation of the relationship. I would like to think that this openness, being open to what there is to be offered, provides the space necessary for people to interact with people, humans with humans, without labels, and to see each other as the image-bearers that we are. Then, we would probably flourish into full humans that be, that know, that do, that feel, that love.
That, however, is a very lofty hope to have of service-learning. I don't think service-learning should be approached with that goal in mind. However, at the very least, service-learning makes us open to listen and to hear stories. That is at least one step in the right direction, even if we never get to where we want to be.
Marianna, you raised some great ideas. Your first idea reminded me of how we often ask young children, "What do you want to be?" when perhaps the better question--and this is what I think you're saying too--is, "Who do you want to be?" The importance of being a person who fits a particular category is... well, less important. This is why service-learning (and hopefully Christian education and the Church, as well) take on the task of caring not only about mastering particular cultural artifacts (Wolterstorff's second stage), but actually empowering people to become more fully human (which means thinking, doing, being, etc.). Your point about narrative seems to fit right into this: how do we become more engaged in the full complexity of humanness in society? The stories around us seems like a great place to start. So, we must be faithful both to hearing as well as to telling the stories.
ReplyDeleteJeff, just reading the title of your essay brought me back to Hungary. Oh Hunter.
ReplyDeleteIt is encouraging to hear about the history of service learning around the country. I did not know that many colleges have been apart of this movement, yet at the same time I am pained by the fact that there are so few colleges presented. Why is justice-seeking not necessarily a common piece of Christian education?
To answer Thad’s question, service-learning is the epitome of living a life “faithfully present” hats off to Hunter, which is what we as human beings are called to be. We live lives in intimate service to our Creator, learning more each day. Concerning being a “human doing”, I am reminded of Jeff saying that we learn with our head, our heart, and our hands—one cannot be separated from any of the other parts. We learn by doing, by living, so I agree wholeheartedly that service-learning is an integral part of being human. We are constantly learning from each other and constantly serving, whether we are serving God, others, or ourselves.
Once we choose to step into an uncomfortable, vulnerable place—one of learning—we gain a greater understanding of the world as it is and start working towards the way the world could be. The choice to participate in service-learning opens us up to empathy, rather than mere pity for our brothers and sisters in Christ. Through service-learning we actually see the world from a different perspective—our itty bitty piece of the world grows a wee bit, thanks be to God. When we as people learn more, further increasing our desire to serve out of love, rather than obligation, our love and faithfulness grows ever stronger. Ah if the world knew the benefits to service-learning even secular schools would more strongly encourage the implementation of such practices!
Jeff, just reading the title of your essay brought me back to Hungary. Oh Hunter.
ReplyDeleteIt is encouraging to hear about the history of service learning around the country. I did not know that many colleges have been apart of this movement, yet at the same time I am pained by the fact that there are so few colleges presented. Why is justice-seeking not necessarily a common piece of Christian education?
To answer Thad’s question, service-learning is the epitome of living a life “faithfully present” hats off to Hunter, which is what we as human beings are called to be. We live lives in intimate service to our Creator, learning more each day. Concerning being a “human doing”, I am reminded of Jeff saying that we learn with our head, our heart, and our hands—one cannot be separated from any of the other parts. We learn by doing, by living, so I agree wholeheartedly that service-learning is an integral part of being human. We are constantly learning from each other and constantly serving, whether we are serving God, others, or ourselves.
Once we choose to step into an uncomfortable, vulnerable place—one of learning—we gain a greater understanding of the world as it is and start working towards the way the world could be. The choice to participate in service-learning opens us up to empathy, rather than mere pity for our brothers and sisters in Christ. Through service-learning we actually see the world from a different perspective—our itty bitty piece of the world grows a wee bit, thanks be to God. When we as people learn more, further increasing our desire to serve out of love, rather than obligation, our love and faithfulness grows ever stronger. Ah if the world knew the benefits to service-learning even secular schools would more strongly encourage the implementation of such practices!