Friday, June 12
Readings:
Readings:
“History of the
Department of Academically Based Service-Learning at Calvin College” by Rhonda
Berg (see email)
--
Some Questions to reflect on:
How would you define service-learning? In what ways has service-learning enhanced, detracted from, or simply coexisted with your traditional, classroom education? Have you seen it as included with your coursework or integrated with it? What difference does this distinction make?
The SLC strategic plan is a couple years old. What work still needs to be done to meet the goals of this document? What modifications should we push for in an updated strategic plan?
The SLC strategic plan is a couple years old. What work still needs to be done to meet the goals of this document? What modifications should we push for in an updated strategic plan?
Upon reading about the history of academically based service learning in the article by Rhonda Berg, I was delighted to read that the movement towards ABSL got off the ground through the work of a small group of people, rather than any being ushered in at the college through large grants or a movement by governing body. It seems as though a philosophical, or theological, shift in the educational direction of the college was best suited to come from the students themselves.
ReplyDeleteA point that I noted to be crucial and I think may often be missed amongst students such as myself was that the original purpose of the ad-hoc committee's insistence in the integration of service to learning was not for its own sake, but rather for the means of education. Our service is never an "end" in and of itself, but rather a crucial opportunity for more deep understanding of our academic field as well as a moment in which we are invited into more tight-knit community with those around us. Going to Cook Library, reading with young children, playing soccer in the vacant lot behind the building, I've got to believe that when done faithfully and intentionally, these actions begin to create a world more and more reminiscent of God's Kingdom.
I have done so reading recently about Howard Gardner's Multiple Intelligences Theory, which simply put is the idea that there are eight or so areas in which each person excels at learning, obviously not all of them being in a classroom. It was stated in the article that credit is not given for service-learning, nor do I believe it should be, but it makes me wonder just how it is we are evaluating the growth and experiences gained by students through exams and quizzes. If we truly desire here at the Service Learning Center for the experiences and opportunities for growth, learning, and service to be transformative in more ways than one, how could we possibly expect the student to then express that change in a ten-question quiz? I think back on some of my most formative S.L. experiences, including my time at Supper House, which then led me to start a student organization to cut down on food waste, and I wonder if I'd be able to pass a short test, quiz, or journal coherently about that time. Perhaps I am at fault for not being as reflective about my experience as I should have, which I something I now see the value in. What I am trying to say is that when we have something as wonderful and as transformative as ABSL, I think it would behoove us to think about evaluating students experiences beyond the standard exam or quiz.
Very interesting. Regarding your comment, "It was stated in the article that credit is not given for service-learning, nor do I believe it should be, but it makes me wonder just how it is we are evaluating the growth and experiences gained by students through exams and quizzes."
DeleteIt reminds me of the following NPR article about transforming the way teachers are taught: http://www.npr.org/sections/ed/2015/06/17/414980239/a-vision-for-teacher-training-at-mit-west-point-meets-bell-labs
The following is a line from that article: "Instead of focusing on courses and credits students need to take," says Levine, who's now head of the foundation, "we're going to focus on the skills and knowledge they need to have to enter the classroom." It's kind of exciting.
Whoops. Calvin S-LC is Mariana, btw.
DeleteI have read through the Strategic Plan at the SLC many times before and although I find it helpful, what caught my eye was the Appendix near the end of the document which listed some of the strengths and the weaknesses. I noticed that one of the weaknesses that was written about was the process of reflection that did not appear to those examining the Plan to be a strong process. This struck me as a bit odd at first, especially as transportation assistant this past year as it was stressed to us drivers to constantly be communicating and asking questions with those we are in the car with regarding their experience and the community. It knocked me back a bit because it sometimes seems as though all we ever do is reflect! (which is not a bad thing at all!) Moving forward, I wonder how we, the staff at the SLC, can not only better streamline that communication and reflection time to be more transparent and accessible, but also continue to work so that mission as a workplace continues to be focused on providing students with transformative experiences?
ReplyDeleteYour response shows that we addressed that weakness, Cameron! :)
DeleteI am not one that is inclined to think about measurable outcomes or SWAT goals when working on formal projects or crossing everyday tasks off of my to-do list. I have been challenged in this area and see the value of these practices, but for me it takes intention to think in this way.
ReplyDeleteThrough reading the Burg article and S-LC strategic plan I was overcome with an overwhelming sense of pressure to contribute as much as possible to the success of creating tangible results, learning outcomes, and numbers to support the work that we do.Then I remembered that I am just a tiny piece of our office and that the goals and shortfalls of the Service-Learning Center's strategic plan are far from my sole responsibility. The history of the S-LC presented in the Burg article is a testament to the truth of thoughtful development, organic growth, and passion guided change.
The initial pressure felt when reading these pieces is void when I see the larger context. Burg connects the philosophy of ABSL strategies as being emphasized by God's sovereignty over all. I find much comfort in this reminder. At the end of the day, the effectiveness of our goals and outcomes are not in our control, but in the control of the God who sees the full picture. How can we strive to work with this assurance while honoring and striving toward our intended goals?
-Libby
I think we're on to something in this discussion of the difficulties of measuring SL outcomes. If you remember a bit of my own story from the Round 1 readings, I did the required SLC stuff while at Calvin but didn't look back on these experiences as formative for years. How could something like that ever be measured? I suspect we can't measure those types of outcomes, but do you all have ideas about what realistic expectations might be for outcomes?
ReplyDeleteI will also state that I'm pleased to read recurring comments on the goal of SLC to be witnessing to God's kingdom (or God's reign). I think this keeps us rooted theologically ("Your Kingdom come") in a way that's larger than institutional goals.
After reading the History of Calvin's Service-Learning Center, I am grateful that ABSL started somewhere, even if it was started as an end to in self, in which service-learning cannot be contained in that small a box. It gives me great hope seeing where the KIDS has come and where it will go this coming year and in future years.
ReplyDeleteI came away from the article wondering where else ABSL exists. Is there a map pointing out the various institutions and places ABSL is at work? Maybe we could talk to the Geo department and make one. Not we need to know numbers, but I think it would be interesting to watch where ABSL is taking place and watch for future positive developments in the areas where ABSL is present.
I was also wondering:
What are a few of the pros and cons, and places the ABSL program can be improved upon since the integration of ABSL into Calvin’s curriculum?
Have there been noticeable changes in the student body since participating in ABSL? Are there ways of checking in with students after they leave Calvin? It would be awesome if there were a way for grads to share how ABSL and/or their participation in the S-LC has/hasn’t shaped their life.
Concerning the SLC Strategic Plan:
How do we as student workers live into the motto “serving to learn, learning to serve”? How do we actively embody this reciprocity?
I understand that through the act of service-learning this happens naturally, but as workers, how do we continue to serve and learn in a parallel reciprocal way?
What do we learn together in the SLC? What do we want to learn? It is my first year working here with everyone so I am interested to see what we learn and how we learn together. Are there any specific/general things we would like each other to walk away with after a year together?
And again going back to grads, I noticed as Cameron was saying, that there are surveys and reflections for students to complete, but I am wondering if there are ways to contact people like Thad, people who made up the fabric of the SLC a few years ago. I am just wondering, if we value our past, do we have a way of cataloguing our past? How do we keep up with or check in how our past students, now professional in the workplace, or past partners are doing now?
Where are the alumni now?
After reading the History of Calvin's Service-Learning Center, I am grateful that ABSL started somewhere, even if it was started as an end to in self, in which service-learning cannot be contained in that small a box. It gives me great hope seeing where the KIDS has come and where it will go this coming year and in future years.
ReplyDeleteI came away from the article wondering where else ABSL exists. Is there a map pointing out the various institutions and places ABSL is at work? Maybe we could talk to the Geo department and make one. Not we need to know numbers, but I think it would be interesting to watch where ABSL is taking place and watch for future positive developments in the areas where ABSL is present.
I was also wondering:
What are a few of the pros and cons, and places the ABSL program can be improved upon since the integration of ABSL into Calvin’s curriculum?
Have there been noticeable changes in the student body since participating in ABSL? Are there ways of checking in with students after they leave Calvin? It would be awesome if there were a way for grads to share how ABSL and/or their participation in the S-LC has/hasn’t shaped their life.
Concerning the SLC Strategic Plan:
How do we as student workers live into the motto “serving to learn, learning to serve”? How do we actively embody this reciprocity?
I understand that through the act of service-learning this happens naturally, but as workers, how do we continue to serve and learn in a parallel reciprocal way?
What do we learn together in the SLC? What do we want to learn? It is my first year working here with everyone so I am interested to see what we learn and how we learn together. Are there any specific/general things we would like each other to walk away with after a year together?
And again going back to grads, I noticed as Cameron was saying, that there are surveys and reflections for students to complete, but I am wondering if there are ways to contact people like Thad, people who made up the fabric of the SLC a few years ago. I am just wondering, if we value our past, do we have a way of cataloguing our past? How do we keep up with or check in how our past students, now professional in the workplace, or past partners are doing now?
Where are the alumni now?